Best Semi-Auto Defensive Shotgun Under $1000

D

Dragline45

New member
What would you all consider the best semi-auto defensive shotgun not exceeding $1000. I have been looking at the Remington 1100, and the Mossberg 930, any downsides to either of these two models? Appreciate any recommendations or input.
 
1100 has been around, basically unchanged, since the early 60s; with a minimum of care they'll last that long and then some without any major issues.
 
I got my slightly used (small scuff in the handguard and VERY lint surface rust on the barrel that came out with some CLP and a bush) Benelli Tactical for $800 this spring. Great gun although I did upgrade parts like the extended magazine, hammer and sear (922r compliance) and put on a lImb saver buttpad. Deals are out there, just be ready to jump when one comes your way.
 
I'm no shotgun expert, and I have an 1100 that works well. IIRC it does have a O-ring problem that can cause reliability issues.

I keep mine around as a backup, but I'd personally first go with a pump gun. Much less expensive and as long as you train, which you should do anyway, you won't short-shuck it.
 
I have had 1100s since 1963 and I have never had an O ring go bad. I have one that has been in service since 1967 and over 100,000 rounds. Call it a test in progress. They do not move in service, they get torn by ham handedness during assembly and disassembly. The reliability issue is a myth UNLESS someone installed a cheap rubber plumber's O ring. Lubricants dissolve those.
 
I say Benelli M3.....and converts to pump-action as well as semi-automatic with a simple twist. But I confess I don't know how much they cost now. Think I paid $900 20 years ago
:D
 
IIRC it does have a O-ring problem that can cause reliability issues.
Click to expand...

I heard the same, though if it came down to it I would just keep a couple spares around and replace it every few years.

The Benelli's are nice, and if I did come across a good deal I would jump on it, but from my experience most people think their guns are worth their weight in gold, and cant understand the concept that used guns sell for less than what they paid new, so I won't hold my breath.
 
I like the pump guns myself , but the 1100 is smooth shooting very reliable for years of service thousands of tounds with very little maintanance .
That being said a thing I have seen and have shown others many times is take metal 5 gallon buckes and heavy field loads with a Remington 1100 and Browning A5 at 25/30 yards . The 1100 will rock it back and forth maby knock it over while the A5 send it flipping end over end . Its a trade off there is still plenty of energy left on the recieving end but you lose alot for that smooth firing weapon . The A5 will recoil like a pump gun while the 1100 gives you a fast follow up .
The only time I have seen a damaged 0 ring on a 1100 is where it was damaged during reassembley .
 
I like the pump guns myself , but the 1100 is smooth shooting very reliable for years of service thousands of tounds with very little maintanance .
That being said a thing I have seen and have shown others many times is take metal 5 gallon buckes and heavy field loads with a Remington 1100 and Browning A5 at 25/30 yards . The 1100 will rock it back and forth maby knock it over while the A5 send it flipping end over end . Its a trade off there is still plenty of energy left on the recieving end but you lose alot for that smooth firing weapon . The A5 will recoil like a pump gun while the 1100 gives you a fast follow up .The only time I have seen a damaged 0 ring on a 1100 is where it was damaged during reassembley .
Click to expand...

Sorry not sure I follow this, are you trying to say that the same load out of a Browning A5 will be more powerful than out of an 1100? Given that they have the same barrel lengths I just don't buy that, that's not how it works. Regardless of what gun you use, that shot is leaving the barrel at the same velocity. The only thing that would effect how it impacts those 5 gallon buckets is the barrel length and choke used due to the difference in spread.
 
No you are wrong . The A5 is recoil operated the 1100 is gas . The A5 hits nearly as hard as a pump or single barrel . The 1100 bleeds of gas , thats why dove hunters prefer them for long shooting days less recoil and a little loss of power is not a bad trade off for felt recoil . If you do not have a A5 try it with a non simi shot gun instead of saying you dont buy that . Any one that has hunted with both can tell the differance . 2 of the same movable targets and same ammo .
 
No you are wrong . The A5 is recoil operated the 1100 is gas . The A5 hits nearly as hard as a pump or single barrel . The 1100 bleeds of gas , thats why dove hunters prefer them for long shooting days less recoil and a little loss of power is not a bad trade off for felt recoil . If you do not have a A5 try it with a non simi shot gun instead of saying you dont buy that . Any one that has hunted with both can tell the differance . 2 of the same movable targets and same ammo .
Click to expand...

Again that's not how it works, just because the gas is being used to automatically work the action doesn't mean the shot coming out of the barrel is moving at a lower velocity. The reason a pump gun has more recoil is because you are getting the full brunt of all that energy, where the auto uses that energy to cycle the bolt, it doesn't change the velocity of the shot coming out of the barrel. In fact im pretty sure the shot has already left the barrel by the time the gun ejects and cycles the next round.

I just posted a new thread asking about this, so well see what some of the more knowledgeable posters will have to say about it.
 
Last edited:
Genarations of hunters and the reaction of moving targets say the A5 action puts more power down range than the 1100 . Not faulting the 1100 and I would prefer one for quicker follow ups . Just try this with similar firearms for yourself .
 
I did cite my refrerences , set up the targets and shoot them . The old Browning action will shoot harder than the 1100 . The gas system on the 1100 does bleed of some energy that the A5 retains .
 
No, YOU claiming something without data is meaningless. You state that "generations of hunters say..."

Sorry, that is as worthless as any Madison Ave marketing crap. No data= no facts

Take the same loads in guns of equal length and barrel length and run them over a chrono with photo-based documentation.
 
Can we skip the "my gun has more power downrange" debate. It's irrelevant to this OP topic.

Whether shot comes from an 1100 or A5 it's going to have the same deadly impact for the recipient (who is not a metal jug, but instead flesh and bone).
 
For defensive purposes, "The gun is the least of it."
Defensive survival skills and mastering the shotgun you have trumps choice of equipment every time.
 
The OP specifically asked about the Mossberg 930. Forget the -CENSORED--CENSORED--CENSORED--CENSORED--CENSORED--CENSORED--CENSORED- contest between Remington and Mossberg, Ford and Chevy, while Mossberg is reputed to turn out a pretty good pump, its semi is another story.

The question is what is the best defensive auto loader for $1,000. I believe that means new for $1,000. don't know how the OP rates one over the other for defensibility, but I would suggest the key factor would be reliability.
 
For defensive purposes, "The gun is the least of it."
Defensive survival skills and mastering the shotgun you have trumps choice of equipment every time.
Click to expand...

That doesn't in any way answer my question...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top