Comparing the best scope with the features you're looking at for under $200.00 is like saying which car is better, a Yugo or a Pinto. There is no answer that is viable. If you want a scope with big knobs with numbers on it that will look all Tommy Taktikewl then waste your money on a BSA, NC Star or other junk like that.
If you want to spend $200 on a 3X9X40 standard duplex then Redfield, Weaver, Nikon, Bushnell and others all make decent offerings that are all very similar, throw the names in a hat and pick one.