I have a BPS and I love it. I have a 12/28/3". I have access to a 10ga BPS so I decided not to get a 3.5" in 12 cause I really don't need it. If I am going goose hunting I just use the 10. I can almost guarantee it will be the smoothest pumping gun you can find for a hunting grade shotgun. I have never had any problems with it. I have taken it completely apart and put it back together again, its simple but most guns aren't too complicated. You can also buy a cantilevered slug barrel if you want to deer hunt with it, so thats another option. Just make sure whatever you buy fits you good, especially with some extra layers on. You don't want to have to move your cheek around a lot, or adjust it farther into your shoulder or anything before you shoot. You should just be able to throw it up and it should fit good. Good luck with the choice.