We drew good tags this year and they were worth the wait. My first ever deer tag was on the Kaibab and I haven't been back since in 24 years. I've learned a lot since then and I've come a long way and so the goal was to shoot good bucks. I needed something for the wall this year, and so did my little brother (Tate). We had 3 tags in camp, a friend I met in grad school (Mike) that puts in with us was on the application as well and we all wanted good bucks.
Fall is a busy time of year and this year is no exception; my little brother is going through some unexpected family issues, I had promised a friend I'd help him on his elk hunt which landed a week before this one, I've got two kids in school and activities, my wife just went back to school a few weeks ago... the point being as much effort I wanted to put into scouting this area before the hunt, I just wasn't able to. I spent my time shooting and had to rely on myself and my friends to find a good buck and that was just the deal. However, the Arizona Kaibab is forgiving for this kind of thing. We had good help, we had a 10 day hunt and we took the whole thing off. Our dad took the time as well and a bunch of friends we went to high school with were either already up there guiding or were able to give us a few days here and there and it made a big difference.
A friend and I went up the weekend before the hunt for one day, a quick overnight trip after butchering a cow elk, and we looked at some areas he knew about and checked out some others. We didn't see any good bucks but we saw some deer in the areas we wanted to see them and when the hunt rolled around we set up camp. Excitement was high.
We split into two hunting groups and had additional glassers once in awhile. Day 1 yielded 8 bucks, one fairly nice 4 point character buck Mike and I decided to pass on. We found some more good glassing country and would later kill a buck in the area.
Group 2 and Day 2, my dad and brother went with our buddy Ben who is a deer-finding machine. Two minutes into good glassing light they had a buck, Ben knows what makes a good buck and his basic description was "Tate, got a shooter. Come here right now and shoot this buck.." There were two, they made sure they had the correct buck and Tate dropped the hammer on a 200 yard shot. First buck on the hunt down! Really cool 5x5, just what were were hoping for:
Side view with our old man:
Same morning we were up in the high country as well and driving in we saw a good 4x4 buck. Mike missed the shot which was a bummer. We saw nothing else that day but had a really good reunion that night over cold beer and good whiskey and campfire light. There were 7 of us that all went to high school together and we tied one on. One of my favorite memories of the hunt. Really fun night and it was great to see everyone.
Days 3 and 4 were concentrated on getting Mike a buck, we weren't seeing anything big between us and the glassers. Most of our help was leaving for the week with the intention of coming back for the last weekend of the hunt. We had several decent bucks patterned and kept after them. Day 4 first thing we were on a group of deer with a distinctive buck who kept picking up different bucks every night. We got into position and had eyes on the hill guiding us in. We were looking at the distinctive character buck when Mike said "there's a big 4-point, great buck, I'm gonna shoot that one." I said ok. I didn't bring up my glass to look at him like I should have, 240 yards and could see horns with the naked eye and I watched without glass. Mike was excited and I said ok kill him. I had seen a good frame thru the oak bramble at one point and assumed that was him. Mike definitely thought it was him.
Mike pulled the shot a bit, we had a 3-4 hour tracking event and this buck was one of those animals that will amaze me forever. The things he did, with a devastating wound, is just unbelievable. I know they are capable of stuff like this but sometimes they really go the extra mile to not get killed. In the end, we won, and our buddy Travis did the best tracking job I've ever witnessed. We got him in the end. Mike's first mule deer:
We had a bit of ground shrinkage here, I think what happened is the wrong buck was killed. There were two bucks in the clearing when he shot. He's a new hunter. I'd be lying to say there wasn't a bit of disappointment here. He was sure he had the buck he wanted but has never evaluated a Muley before. I'm not a professional guide.
Fall is a busy time of year and this year is no exception; my little brother is going through some unexpected family issues, I had promised a friend I'd help him on his elk hunt which landed a week before this one, I've got two kids in school and activities, my wife just went back to school a few weeks ago... the point being as much effort I wanted to put into scouting this area before the hunt, I just wasn't able to. I spent my time shooting and had to rely on myself and my friends to find a good buck and that was just the deal. However, the Arizona Kaibab is forgiving for this kind of thing. We had good help, we had a 10 day hunt and we took the whole thing off. Our dad took the time as well and a bunch of friends we went to high school with were either already up there guiding or were able to give us a few days here and there and it made a big difference.
A friend and I went up the weekend before the hunt for one day, a quick overnight trip after butchering a cow elk, and we looked at some areas he knew about and checked out some others. We didn't see any good bucks but we saw some deer in the areas we wanted to see them and when the hunt rolled around we set up camp. Excitement was high.
We split into two hunting groups and had additional glassers once in awhile. Day 1 yielded 8 bucks, one fairly nice 4 point character buck Mike and I decided to pass on. We found some more good glassing country and would later kill a buck in the area.
Group 2 and Day 2, my dad and brother went with our buddy Ben who is a deer-finding machine. Two minutes into good glassing light they had a buck, Ben knows what makes a good buck and his basic description was "Tate, got a shooter. Come here right now and shoot this buck.." There were two, they made sure they had the correct buck and Tate dropped the hammer on a 200 yard shot. First buck on the hunt down! Really cool 5x5, just what were were hoping for:
Side view with our old man:
Same morning we were up in the high country as well and driving in we saw a good 4x4 buck. Mike missed the shot which was a bummer. We saw nothing else that day but had a really good reunion that night over cold beer and good whiskey and campfire light. There were 7 of us that all went to high school together and we tied one on. One of my favorite memories of the hunt. Really fun night and it was great to see everyone.
Days 3 and 4 were concentrated on getting Mike a buck, we weren't seeing anything big between us and the glassers. Most of our help was leaving for the week with the intention of coming back for the last weekend of the hunt. We had several decent bucks patterned and kept after them. Day 4 first thing we were on a group of deer with a distinctive buck who kept picking up different bucks every night. We got into position and had eyes on the hill guiding us in. We were looking at the distinctive character buck when Mike said "there's a big 4-point, great buck, I'm gonna shoot that one." I said ok. I didn't bring up my glass to look at him like I should have, 240 yards and could see horns with the naked eye and I watched without glass. Mike was excited and I said ok kill him. I had seen a good frame thru the oak bramble at one point and assumed that was him. Mike definitely thought it was him.
Mike pulled the shot a bit, we had a 3-4 hour tracking event and this buck was one of those animals that will amaze me forever. The things he did, with a devastating wound, is just unbelievable. I know they are capable of stuff like this but sometimes they really go the extra mile to not get killed. In the end, we won, and our buddy Travis did the best tracking job I've ever witnessed. We got him in the end. Mike's first mule deer:
We had a bit of ground shrinkage here, I think what happened is the wrong buck was killed. There were two bucks in the clearing when he shot. He's a new hunter. I'd be lying to say there wasn't a bit of disappointment here. He was sure he had the buck he wanted but has never evaluated a Muley before. I'm not a professional guide.
Last edited: