Another self-defense shooting

Eric of IN

New member
No charges filed in store shootings

Police say man, 70, who killed one suspect and wounded another who fled, acted in self-defense.

By Monica Scandlen

The Indianapolis Star


Last updated 01:03 AM, EST, Saturday, May 20, 2000

The would-be robbers who tried to hold up a Near-Eastside mom-and-pop variety store couldn't have known it, but this time 70-year-old George Smith was packing.

Smith, a friend of the Shelbyville couple who have run JM Distributors for 21 years, was shot outside the store the last time something like this happened in 1998.

So he bought a gun. Two years later, when intruders came again, Smith was ready.

The result: one suspect dead, another wounded.

"We'd be dead if it wasn't for George," said Judy Moore, 50, whose husband, Jerry, was working outside the store when the holdup men walked in just before 5 p.m. Thursday. "I think George was the real hero. He saved my life."

Back in the shop Friday, Jerry Moore didn't have the stomach to clean all the blood off some of his store shelves. Some shelves he just had to toss.

"It's terrible, terrible, what happened," Moore, 57, said as he mopped the floor of his general store in the 3700 block of Massachusetts Avenue. "We're just a little family store."

But it's a store that Moore says had been visited by robbers twice before in the past two years.

The last time, Smith was severely wounded and was laid up in a hospital for weeks. As a frequent visitor to his friends' shop, the Moores say, he wanted to be ready the next time.

He was.

Corey Jermaine Price, 22, was shot in the head and died about midnight Thursday in Methodist Hospital. Indianapolis police are still looking for Price's accomplice. Police said Price and his 21-year-old alleged accomplice shared a home in the 1300 block of North Chester Avenue.

Despite a sign on the store's door that read "Closed today," a steady stream of people wanted to see how the Moores and Smith, their friend of 15 years, were doing.

"I just came by to see if you were OK," said a UPS delivery man who picked up a candy bar at the shop.

As for Smith, he was in no mood to talk of heroics. Neither were the Moores.

"We feel so sad," Judy Moore said. "This young man was so desperate for money, but who knows, he might have shot us both."

Homicide Detective Thomas Lehn and the Moores gave this account of what happened Thursday:

Smith was in the front of the store when Price and the other man entered just before 5 p.m. wearing women's stockings over their heads. Judy Moore was in the office in the back.

Price pointed a gun at Smith and pushed him. Smith pretended to have a heart attack and fell to the floor.

Then Price went into the office and confronted Judy Moore. Price's accomplice stayed near the cash register. Terrified, Judy Moore began screaming.

"I thought I was going to die, I really did," she said.

Price seemed to be looking for something in the office. When he didn't find it, he went back to the front of the store.

He found Smith waiting. Price again pointed a gun at Smith who by then had pulled out his own weapon. Smith fired at both men, hitting Price in the head and his accomplice in the left shoulder, Lehn said.

Price fell to the floor, and his partner fled.

Seconds later, Jerry Moore, who had heard the ruckus from outside, rushed in.

While police responded to a 911 call from Judy Moore, the fleeing suspect showed up at Winona Memorial Hospital, according to police. He arrived at 6:10 p.m., was briefly treated for his wound and left at 6:25 p.m. -- before police, summoned by hospital staff, could arrive.

Since then, the accomplice has been in contact with his family, Lehn said, and might have left the Indianapolis area. Police intend to charge him with attempted robbery -- and also felony murder because of the death of Price during the commission of a felony.

Smith will not be charged. Prosecutors and detectives have concluded the shooting was justified self-defense, and Smith had a permit to carry the gun.

Today, JM Distributors will open its doors for business once again.

---------------------------------------------
I hate the headline. It implies that what he did was wrong.
Eric


------------------
Formerly Puddle Pirate.
Teach a kid to shoot.
It annoys the antis.
 
I'm amazed the Indy Star would run the story. It would have never been in the Kokomo (Omokok) Tribune if the same thing would have happened 40 miles north of indy.
 
Thanks for posting this. When Sen. Tom Daschle reads his list of children killed by guns on the Senate floor, I wonder if anyone will call him on this one. Robert
 
I commend the Star for running this story. I like living in boring and quiet Indiana. We can carry here. A couple of years ago, an old guy was being robbed in a parking lot at a local grocery store. The old guy shot the kid dead where he stood.
You sure hate to see anyone get shot, but I am glad the innocent victim came out on top. This young dead man probably became a statistic to be used against us. The bad guys continue to be a pain in the ##s even when they are dead!

------------------
"I learned a thing or two from Charlie,don't you know. You better stay away from Copperhead Road" Steve Earle
 
I'm always curious as to gun and cartridge selection in such shootings. Do we know what Mr.Smith carried in either category.

BTW - I love it when armed stick up merchants get the instant cure, 'attaboy old timer (said softly)

Mike H
 
Score one for the good guys.


A also wonder about the caliber and gun. I would guess a Glock since they are so popular, easy to operate, and inexpensive. Or, since he was an old timer, maybe a revolover?


Yep, the "poor bad guy" was desperate for money. I guess he should have gotten a JOB! rather than run around with illegal weapons, threatening lives, all for a few bucks in a robbery. There are "now hiring" signs all over the place where I live. It has never taken me more than a day to find a minimum wage job when I want one. And, mimimum wage is reasonable enough that this guy could have earned a few hundred bucks real easy through honest means rather than crime. It ain't that tough to get a job and make something of yourself. This is America, no healthy person has an excuse to go hungry in this country. I have no pity on people that commit crimes to make a few bucks instead of getting a job, and then they/we all whine about how they were forced into crime because they needed money. Yeah, right.
 
It was great for the paper to run that story.
Unfortunately, nobody outside of Indianapolis will read about it. Now, if it had been two "children" who got into trouble with guns...

Dick
 
A funny thing happened here in south bend this week, a guy and a his brothers got in a fight with a bouncer and the bouncer pulled his gun the brothers ran and the one drunk guy got shot and was running away the brothers were in the truck trying to get away. The bouncer fired another shot and shot out the back window of the truck. They Ducking down peeled out and ran over their brother who was shot, killing him and dragging him in the process. the coroner ruled he was killed by the truck and not from the gunshot.
Funny story huh?
 
Back
Top