Analysis: Why Elian Lost (long)

Oatka

New member
These will become two-a-penny before it's all over. Here's a good one, based on what we know right now. Note No. 4.
http://www.newsmax.com/articles/?a=2000/4/22/103053

Analysis: Why Elian Lost
Christopher Ruddy
April 22, 2000 11:22 AM EST

Miami -- When I arrived at the scene outside of Elian's home the smell of tear gas was still in the air.

I was there just minutes after Federal Marshals had conducted a gestapo raid on the home of law abiding citizens -- to snatch a young child. This is the first time in the history of the United States federal agents using rifles settled a custody case.

I had been up about 5 AM and was planning to pick up syndciated radio host Michael Reagan, to bring him to Elian's home.

Michael told me last night he had brought with him cuff links worn by his father as president. This cherished gift from his father Michael planned to give to Elian.

This reminded me of a speech Ronald Reagan once gave in Miami. He promised Cuba would be liberated. He reportedly brought the house down with cheers.

Though Reagan tore the Berlin Wall down, Cuba is still not free.

In fact, Castro's Cuba is among the few Stalinist regimes left on the planet.

That's why Elian's mother risked the shark infested waters to bring her son here. This is why so many -- and we still don't how many -- have died escaping Fidel's "paradise."

The problem was never Elian, the father, custody issues, etc. The issue was, and is, Castro. For four decades the American press has looked the other way as his brutal regime represses the most basic human rights every man and woman desire.

Elian will now be returned to Castro.
John LeBoutillier, writing in NewsMax.com, foretold the snatching of Elian.

After the joyous court ruling this past week, when everyone was celebrating, John concluded they were going to seize the kid. John's logic was simple: Reno and friends had to get control of the kid to have him change his mind before his asylum hearing.
Reno claimed she worried the kid would be abused.

I worry now what will happen to the child in the hands of Castro's men. That same fear caused Sister Jean to turn her mind 180 degrees. A bona fide liberal, she saw through Clinton's machinations on behalf of Castro.

What more abuse could you cause a child than to have armed men in black suits come storming into his bedroom, with automatic rifles, to steal him for his loving environment and to be whisked away by still more strange men.

Janet Reno has always operated on the basis of twisted logic. She justified the federal holocaust at Waco because, she claimed, there was evidence of child abuse.

Child abuse is a constant theme in her career, and, in her mind, allows for even the killing of the person being abused!
Reno got away with Waco. She got away with covering for Clinton, scandal after scandal.

She got away with covering up for the Chinagate scandal. Without accountability, why should she stop acting recklessly?

After repeated visits to Little Havana during this crisis, after conferring with Jack Thompson, our reporter on the scene, and after meeting several times with the Cuban leadership here, it became too apparent to me that Elian's situation was very bad. Let me explain the basic reasons why I thought Elian was in deep trouble:
1. No Strategy.

The Miami relatives and Cuban-American leadership never had a clear strategy and were constantly reacting.

David Horowitz, in his booklet "The Art of Political Warfare" writes that the side that has a strategy -- when fighting against a side that doesn't have one -- will always win.

Clinton and company clearly had a strategy. For weeks they have been laying the groundwork for the raid. The father was brought to the U.S. with wife and child -- creating a powerful family image. (The press gave almost no attention that both of Elian's grandmothers's were in detention and apparently being held hostage).

Meanwhile, administration friendly press conducted poll after poll indicating most Americans wanted Elian "returned to his father." (Who would be against that? The fact is the child is being returned to Castro where Castro has a "readaptation" center prepared for him.). More recent polls supported taking the child by force.

The administration stragegy continued: a government paid psychologist, close to Hillary Clinton, who had never met with the boy, determined he was being abused and likened his situatiuon to being held hostage. This "doctor" recommended the boy be rescued immediately.

Then there was Mr. Smoothie, Craig Greg, the same legal eagle brought in to get the President off his impeachment charges, demanding that poor Juan Gonzalez should have his son returned.

As the administration laid the groundwork for this horrific seizure, the Cuban-Americans had an elderly, heavily accented man act as their spokesman.

They made mistake after mistake. For example, they gave hostile press like ABC News an exclusive interview with the boy. ABC then carefully edited and downplayed the interview. Later the family made a bold and wise move to release a home video of the boy saying he wanted to stay in America, but it was too late.

2. Conflicted Loyalties.
I was surpised to see how factionalized the Cuban-American community was here.
The "Democracy Movement" led by Ramon Sanchez was calling the shots, but the much more influential Cuban-American Foundation, I sensed, was not so gung-ho for confrontation over this issue, perhaps because of Sanchez's lead role.

A former Reagan official that dealt with the Cuban-American community during the 1980s explained to me that she was always quite surprised by how divided the Cuban-Americans were.

It was a common belief in the Reagan White House that Castro had thoroughly infiltrated most of the groups in Miami to create as much dissension among them. "This was the model used by the East European satellite nations -- putting agents in the exile movements -- and Castro did the same thing," the Reagan aide explained.

There were other conflicting loyalties.
Alex Penelas, the Mayor of Miami-Dade, is Cuban-American, but he is also a rising star in the Democratic Party. He has been a major fund raiser for Bill Clinton, Hillary Clinton and Al Gore. Penelas made some strong statements at the outset of the crisis, but has been backpedalling ever since.

The vice chairman of the Dade County Democratic Party was Sanchez's right hand man during the whole crisis. He brought on Kendall Coffey, a long time friend of Reno's and the former Clinton appointed U.S.

Attorney in Miami, to be lead counsel for Elian. Who's kidding who? Where are the loyalties of such people? Obviously the Democrats in Miami-Dade have made their bed with Clinton and they are still sharing it.
When Penelas and Miami City Mayor Joe Carollo visited Washington this week it was again clear to me the Clinton administration strategy was at work.

The Justice Department needed the cooperation of the local police. I am sure that was the real reason for the meeting. I asked Carollo point blank this morning if he had any idea the raid would take place, or if the police cooperated in any way. He said "No," and shook his head. He had to say that.

When Penelas arrived the crowd swarmed around him, not to welcome him, but to shout at him. They we chanting, "Renounce the Democratic ticket!" The people here know exactly what the score was with Penelas and the leadership.

3. Republicans Hid.
As has become typical with the Republican leadership during the Clinton reign, they have been out to lunch in times of crisis.
Despite the usual lip service, George Bush has been quiet in Austin and ditto for his brother Jeb in Talahassee. The Republicans in Congress remain as hopeless as ever. They were much more effective as a minority. Like all politicians, they are looking at polls. The polls may show a majority of Americans want Elian to be "returned to his father" -- but they also show at least a third of the coutry opposed such a move.

This one-third of America is largely the base of the Republican Party. Elections are not always won by majorities (Clinton won two in a row with less than 50% of the vote), but they are always won on the margins.

Republican voters may just do what they did in the 1998 Congressional elections, stay home.

Since the Republicans never really held anyone accountable for the massive federal abuse of power at Ruby Ridge, Waco, or even with the President's crimes laid out in the impeachment -- don't count on it happening here. The Cuba-Americans clearly failed to hold the Republicans feet to the fire.

4. People Power.
The biggest thing Elian and his Miami relatives had going for them was "people power" -- the raw showing of popular democracy. For all their talk of "human shields," the Cuban-American leadership here never really created one around Elian's home. I remember when Jack Thompson and I first visited the area outside the home.

Jack turned to me and said, "This is a joke, the feds can come any time and take this kid."

We both noted that the so-called "human shield" was barricaded a hundred feet at one end of the street. The other end had no protesters, was closed by the police and gave ample opportunity for anyone to ride right up to the house.

The Feds did just that. Though they still feared "people power," they came in the dark of the night -- much like the Roman centurians who feared the masses around Jesus.

John LeBoutiller wrote urgently this week that the Feds were coming -- and that people power would work by putting Elian in a Catholic Church. It is doubtful federal agents would have stormed a church building with automatic rifles.

Even still, if the Cuban-American leadership had just a row or two of people around Elian's home, I doubt the Feds would have stormed it. It was apparent from casual observation that the boy was for the taking. Penelas knew that. The Cuban-Amercian leadership obviously knew that -- and did not take steps to avoid it.

5. Cuban Issue.
In failing to strategize the Cuban-American failed to demonstrate this was not a Cuban-American issue. The press was quick to pin this on the Cuban-Americans and to demonize them. Many members of the press wore "Camp Elian" press cards that depicted a banana with a Cuban flag sticking out from it.

Instead of bringing in non-Cubans to speak in Elian's favor, the leadership stuck with Cuban-American stars like Gloria Estefan and Andy Garcia. What they really needed was an actor like Charlton Heston, and political figures like George Bush and Jeb Bush, and other famous political, church and media personalities.

The battle for custody for Elian was lost but much good has come out of this, and still may.

For one thing more people have focused on Castro and his corrupt regime. And with the photo of Elian being taken at gun point, we can graphically understand the meaning of "child abuse" and of a government gone berserk.

The Cuban-American leadership has had many shortcomings, but it's incumbent on Americans every where to recognize this is much more than a "Cuban" story. It is one about freedom and one that should concern every decent American.




------------------
The New World Order has a Third Reich odor.
 
This is a case of leftists, in America and Cuba, cooperating. Clinton and Castro. Clinton is only one step removed from Castro politicaly.
Whatever one may think about the custody issue itself, how can you give the go-ahead to do a dynamic entry to take a child from his relatives. The boy wasn't in danger from his relatives. The dynamic entry in this situation was crossing the line in a big way. At one point an MP5 was pointed almost in the kid's face.
MP5s...What were the FEDs going to do? Shoot the relatives if they resisted too much? Shoot the crowd?
Clinton and his ilk were much too eager to give this child back to Castro. Willing to gas Americans to do it. Willing to shoot apearantly. If they weren't willing to shoot, they wouldn't have brought MP5s. What they should have had was 12 bores with bean bag loads and tazers. Idealy they shouldn't have done what they did at all.
Look at this! A Tac team to take a child from family members just to appease a Communist on an Island.
Leftists in action. I do not believe Reagan, Bush, or Dole, would have done this.
 
Well, if you really hate a foriegn governmenrt, you decalre war on it and pay the price for over running it. I don't remember any of our presidents from Eisenhower to the present ever seriously considering the honorable option in our relations with Cuba.
Makes for good political hot air, though.

[This message has been edited by Herodotus (edited April 22, 2000).]
 
To all of you who are crying about the way the US government handled this issue: I say about damn time. The child was an illegal alien in our country--that is it plain and simple! The INS officials are constantly fighting this battle on the borders. Nobody cries or whimpers when illegal drug traffikers are busted or vanloads of illegal aliens are caught attempting to gain access to our country. How is this different!! What would you like for us to do next? Allow the kid to stay? Well then we would be hypocrites and have to open our borders to everyone. Where do we draw the line!? The kid belongs to his father...not the uncle! The majority of you whining have probably never served proudly in our countries armed forces. We have died protecting our borders so whiners like you can rant and rave with the freedom of speech you have not earned! We, the soldiers, sailors, airmen and marines have fought to give you this! You are just taking it all for granted. If you don't like this WONDERFUL country we live in, then pack your bags and GET THE HELL OUT! Go to Cuba, Russia or any place at all outside our borders. In about a week you will be crying to be let back in! You can only take advantage of the things you have. Once they are gone, you are S.O.L.! In my opinion, it is more of a shame how long was spent negotiating in the first place. Elian was basically being held hostage. Should have happened sooner!
 
BM,
Hey REMF!I am a former Marine, Infantry. And if you can't tell the differance between a six year-old who's mother died fleeing a communist country, and van of drug dealers, you need help.
Isolationist crap! Go tell the displaced Cubans in Miami who saw their relatives killed by the Communists how they have no place here. Castro loves scholars like you REMF.
Oh, thanks for your sacrafice. Thanks for letting me wine on your internet.
Not wanting to let Castro have the boy makes me unpatriotic? We have Marines risking their ass at the bay because of this Stalinist. Isolationist REMF!
So you just like the idea of dangerous foreign six year-old being deported. It's simple for you isn't it?
How do you fit a computer in your alpha pack? Oh, that's right! You don't have to. You're a REMF. Admin\Supply commando, right?
 
Shin-Tao,

We can't all be Marines
smile.gif


I'm an AF vet who thinks BM is full of it. Nevertheless, I served with honor (during Viet Nam) and never fired a shot in anger.
 
Back
Top