454 casull/45 colt dies

N

nhyrum

New member
I'm getting a Taurus raging judge in the near future, and am starting to accumulate reloading supplies. From what I hear, freedom arms recommends separate dies(from what I've seen, only rcbs makes separate dies, and there's only a .001 difference). But, since I don't have a freedom arms, and since there's not much of a difference, does one really need separate dies?
 
I thought that the Judge only shot .45 (long) Colt and not .454 Casull?

.454 Casull dies can load .45 Colt but not the other way around due to case length and cartridge over all length.
 
It ain't fun out of a Ruger super redhawk either. I have separate dies for my Redhawk. And yes, you do need them. A Lee factory crimp die handles either however.
 
When I first bought my SW 460 XVR, I hadn't gotten dies for it yet but was dying to shoot it. So I used my RCBS Carbide 45 Colt Die set and made both 454 Casull, and 460 Magnum.

I later bought a set of carbide Redding dies for the 460/454 and you know what, I like the ammo loaded on the Colt dies better.

The RCBS will full length resize the 454 and 460 no problems.

YMMV.
 
Chainsaw. said:
454 out of a judge? That's not gonna be fun.
Click to expand...
Honestly... I can't wait. It's deffinetley not a gun I'll blast through 50 rounds of ammo in in a sitting(I'll probably shoot a cylinder a day at least) it's a "walking through the woods.... OH S***!! CHARGING GRIZZ!! gun. But at around 5 pounds naked, and a 6 inch barrel, I'm sure it will be manageable
 
.454 Casull dies can load .45 Colt but not the other way around due to case length and cartridge over all length.
Click to expand...
This information is WRONG. Dies for the SHORTER case can be used to load longer cases, but not the other way around.
 
This information is WRONG. Dies for the SHORTER case can be used to load longer cases, but not the other way around.
Click to expand...

In some cases, longer dies won't work for shorter cartridges because the seating stem won't reach the shorter cases but in the case of 45 colt, most 454 seating dies will work just fine.

Like 38 special/357magnum and 44 special/44 magnum are to each other, 45 colt is to 454 casull.

Where you can have a problem is sizing LONGER cases with SHORTER dies. But in the case of the RCBS 45 Colt dies, I am able to full length size 454 and 460 S&W mag with the 45 COLT dies.

And of course, seating and crimping the LONGER cartridge with the SHORTER die is not an issue at all.
 
Last edited:
Where you can have a problem is sizing LONGER cases with SHORTER dies.
Click to expand...
Again, wrong, or at least misleading, information. ALL straight-wall resizing is done with the small carbide ring at the mouth of the die, so any case that can be fully inserted into a die will be properly resized when the die reaches the shell holder. It is theoretically possible for some case to be too long to fit into the sizing die, but this does not happen with any normal revolver calibers.

The real issue has nothing to do with the bullet seating plug - AFAIK, ALL dies have sufficiently long seating stems for sister calibers. the PROBLEM is that a die specifically made for a longer case generally CANNOT be properly adjusted to crimp the bullet in a shorter case - the crimping shelf is just too high in the seating die. And in the case of Lee dies, the powder-thru expander die must have the proper length expander plug for the shortest case.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top