I'm curious, is there anything wrong with choosing say a .35 remington, which is currently available OTC?
No it is not the .357 max; it's a pretty different round all around. Is there a reason it has to be the .357 max? other than moderate (maybe) recoil, I can't see any advantage to it. Either a 30-30 or a .35 rem will give much greater penetration and trajectory. The .44 magnum and .444 marlin will give superior power with a heavier bullet. Seriously, why a .357 max? I'm looking at that as being a little short of perfect for anything bigger than a good sized whitetail.
It will surely work, but it is less than optimal, imo.