What is the intended use, self defense, hunting, or paper punching? Just about any .357 will give a large report and impressive flash. They’ll all punch the same size hole in a paper target and at about the same place inside 15 yards.
So for target shooting, any one will do. For hunting and especially self-defense, I’d go with a round that had published data on terminal performance. Expansion and weight retention mean nothing to a paper target and almost everything to living, breathing creatures.