2 CASES OF "YOU DID IT!" in PA.....

cjb

New member
After reading FUD's thread on you pointed a gun at me.... I started to get angry. I know of 2 cases of firearms related incedents that happened here in pa. within the last 2 years... You may be suprized at the outcomes!

CASE 1:
A man about 22 years old gets a permit to carry, and buys a glock 19. He shoots it often at the local ranges, and joins his friends at many shooting clubs to share thier love of shooting. All of these guys know what the other shoots, and packs on the street.
One evening a friend asks to borrow the Glock owners truck to move his things to a new home. The guys agree on a drop off, and return point for the truck, and everything is great. That night at around 10:00 pm ( well after the return time) the Glock owner notices that his truck is about 5 hrs late. He calls the mans home many times, but gets no answers. After a while, he leaves a message telling him that he wants his truck back, and that he is less than happy about the situation. At around midnight, the guy brings the truck back, he has his wife along, who says that the message was full of nasty words, and was a threat to them. The two men argue for a few mins. then go thier seperate ways. Later that night, the state police show up and ask the man for his gun. He goes and returns with it. The officer says "yep, thats it... a Glock 19". " We will be taking this with us".
The court battle was a long one... all of about 20 mins. The man lost his Glock, and was put on two years probation for the simple fact that the friend and his wife claimed that he pulled the gun on them, and that they could identify the handgun. ITS THAT SIMPLE!!!

CASE 2:
A man and his son were deer hunting in the fields across from thier home. After a un sucessfull day, they returned home to find 2 police cars in the driveway. It turns out that a house about 1000 yards away was shot that morning, and the home owner told the police that she knew it had to be them. The man lost all of his guns, and the the police said that the box of .243 ammo for his hunting rifle "looked" like the one that was found in the wall of the home.... which turns out to be a .30 caliber bullet. This case is STILL under investigation, and the man still does not have his guns back ( since Nov.) I doubt he will ever see them again.
It just goes to show you that if other people don't like you.... you CAN and WILL loose your guns!!!!! Even if you know that there is no way you can be found guilty!! Judges have no respect, or love for gun owners... and they WILL take them from you!!!
( I just wonder where that Glock 19 is now???)

These stories were told to me in our shop. I know everyone involved, and while I will never have all the details, I have little faith in the justice system here in PA.

CJB

------------------
" I SHOOT BACK! "
 
<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by cjb:
After reading FUD's thread on you pointed a gun at me.... I started to get angry. I know of 2 cases of firearms related incedents that happened here in pa. within the last 2 years... You may be suprised at the outcomes!

[/quote]

Where in PA did these incidents happen?
In case 1, the cops had no authority to take the guy's G19 (I would have requested the watch commander's presence before any other discussion with that state cops...I'd also required a receipt for my property prior to any release to the cops.
In case 2...hmmmm, no comment here.

Sounds like the Philadelphia area to me.
 
I would like to know more about these incidents. Does anyone have the police reports or the "judgement and sentence," order of forfeiture, etc. There must be more to it than being reported. Of course there is usually more than one side to a question. It looks to me like the guy must have cut a deal to be placed on probation. It didn't just happen. Perhaps he should have rolled the dice and went to trial. Sounds like the "victims" could have been impeached by their refusal to bring his truck back in time and that this guy could have called in several witnesses from those who knew him from the range. We will probably never know the full story but I think there is more to it than what's been reported. That goes for both incidents. The hunter should file a writ of replevin for his firearms.
 
Not to change the subject (much), but in Connecticut, pretty much anyone who wants to can allege that a gun owner is a few bricks short of a load (and therefore a danger to himself or others), and the constabulary can come in and seize that person's guns. So disgruntled ex-spouses, partners, ex-spouses' disgruntled partners, whomever, can have open season on gun owners. There is, apparently, a hearing process, but once the guns are in the hands of the gendarmes it's hell to pay getting them back.

I'm glad I'm an EX-CT resident...

Do ya'll think there are so damn many liberals in the Northeast because the good guys all left, or did us good guys all leave because there are so damn many liberals? This, truly, is a chicken-or-the-egg question...

------------------
Every nation has the government it deserves. - Joseph de Maistre
 
SAGewehr:

Same situation applies here in Australia; complaints by ex-spouses etc. will see your guns gone, and you have to face a tribunal to get 'em back.

A Club member had an argument with his neighbour over the height of a brick dividing fence. The neighbour is Jewish. As the argument got heated, our Club member said, "During the war I fought to save people like you in Europe. Maybe I was shooting the wrong bloody people". Note that NO guns were involved at any time -- this was purely verbal.

Neighbour complained to police; police seized Club member's guns. Club member went to firearms tribunal who ordered his guns returned BUT they were to be stored at the local police station and he could only sign them in and out to shoot Club matches, with time limits etc. To appeal to the Supreme Court would have cost him tens of thousands of dollars in lawyer's fees, which as a retiree he just didn't have.

Club member sold his guns and resigned from Club.

B
 
Connecticut; are you listening? You're well down the road Australia and Canada, and Great(?) Britain have taken...

The word "ironic" doesn't begin to cover the logical paradox represented by the fact that some of the states who led the way to freedom, including NY, CT, MA, MD and RI have the most repressive laws regarding RKBA.

------------------
Every nation has the government it deserves. - Joseph de Maistre
 
My Father went through a similar situation (sorta) several years back.
Having had pigeons roosting under the eaves, Dad got tired of their incessant cooing, and decided to drop a few with a pellet gun.
A while later an LEO showed up, and confronted him abouth the charges he had shot out some neighbors windows. Specifically some older windows at a higher elevation. My father promptly told him she was FOS, that his son(me) had shot those hole over 30 years ago. The LEO investigated by looking closely at the holes, and found caked dirt in all the holes, from years of age.
He dismissed her allegations, and told my father that it was improper to kill the pigeons in the city limits, etc, and left.

I was about 13 years old when I shot those windows, because I was PO'd at the woman who lived there then, and worked off the damages over the summer. I also got my hide tanned by Dad for doing it too. Stupid thing to do, and something learned.

Best Regards,
Don

------------------
The most foolish mistake we could make would be to allow the subjected people to carry arms;
History shows that all conquerers who have allowed their subjected people to carry arms have prepared their own fall.
Adolf Hitler
-----------------
"Corrupt the young, get them away from religion. Get them interested in sex. Make them superficial, and destroy their rugged- ness.
Get control of all means of publicity, and thereby get the peoples' mind off their government by focusing their attention on athletics, sexy books and plays, and other trivialities.
Divide the people into hostile groups by constantly harping on controversial matters of no importance."

Vladimir Ilich Lenin, former leader of USSR
 
I know the young man in case number one very well. We speak a few times a month, and I have known him for years. He did get a receipt for the taking of his Glock. And he DID get a $2000 attorney, and he did fight it for all he had. He lost alot of money, his Glock, and was put on probation for Terroristic threats. There was no proof of any kind..PERIOD! His word against the other two. The judge told him that he would not get his gun back. And he had to pay $300 to clear his record now that his probation is over. He cut NO DEALS.... he was put on probation because the judge said that something had to be done since the case involved a gun.(which nobody saw). Thats about as much as I can tell you. It's over now, and the guy said that he will never buy another gun. He is married now, and has a baby on the way. "Guns just aint worth it" he said. That's sad.... but he got raped by the justice system!!! By the way... this happened in south central Pa.

Case 2 is not over yet, (I guess). He also got a receipt for his guns. The part that I found odd was... Since this was a stray bullet IN HUNTING SEASON... why did the state police come, and not the game comission????? Sounds like 2 neighbors fighting to me... BUT HE LOST HIS GUNS for now. If I hear anything more, I will post it.

I was just trying to let you all know that YOU CAN loose all of your guns just because someone dosen't like you. Even if you are right, and you know you are legal. Be ready for a major fight... and save your money. YOU WILL NEED IT!!!
CJB
 
Back
Top