2-1/4" barrel vs. 3-1/16" barrel?

almark

New member
I'm thinking about getting a revolver in .357 magnum that I could use for concealed carry (specifically I was thinking of a "drop in the coat pocket on my way out the door" type of gun). I like the feel of the Rugers so I was pretty well set on those, but they offer SP101s with a 2-1/4" barrel, and one with a 3-1/16" barrel. Which would y'all choose? Does the extra 13/16" make any significant difference in the velocity of the bullet as it leaves the barrel? Will it make any significant improvement in accuracy? Will it significantly impact how "concealable" it is? Any other aspects of the situation I should think about?

So much to think about... my head hurts now... :(
 
If you are considering the Ruger I'd strongly consider the 3" barrel if it is available in your area.

Reading on these boards, and experimenting at home, it seems that a 3" K-framed size gun isn't too hard to conceal. A J-frame sized gun should be pretty easy in 3" (the SP101 is roughly J-frame sized). The main concealment difference in a J-frame sized gun is for pocket carry- a 2" is much easier to conceal in a pocket as some pockets won't hold a 3" barrelled gun. However, the Ruger is heavy enough that most people can't really carry it in a pocket anyway. Thus, if you were looking at a Taurus or S&W which are lighter (especially an aluminum, titanium or scandium version) I'd say go with the 2" for the extra possibilities (pocket carry and easier ankle carry), but with the Ruger the 3" isn't going to give you any disadvantages.

As for accuracy, as they say the 2" guns aren't inherently any less accurate than a longer barrel. It is purely a human equation there- most people find the longer sight radius easier to aim accurately. Thus, you'll need to see for yourself what the difference is for you.

The biggest advantage of the 3" (in addition to greater practical accuracy for most, but not all, people) is in velocity. A .38spl, .38+P or .357mag in a 2" barrel loses a lot of velocity- enough that until some of the newest JHP designs they often had trouble expanding. A 3" barrel will give a tad more velocity and thus greater penetration, greater odds that the HP will expand, and a tad more "power".

So again, if you want the Ruger I'd probably go with a 3" if it is available in your area. The 3" is fairly rare though (comparatively anyway), and I'm not sure the advantages are great enough to special order. If all you can find in your area is the 2" then if I was you I'd go with the 2".
 
The biggest advantage of most 3 inchers is the ejector rod is longer making shell extraction a little bit easier.
 
I have the Ruger SP101 in a 2 1/2" barrel without the hammer spur. I love the gun. It makes for a great grab and go gun. I have not had any problems with bullet velocity. In informal testing it seems to be about the same as my security six in a 4".
 
Or, you could always do like most of us..

...and buy one of each! Just kidding, can't afford to own one of everything I want, but I spend enough time lookin' and dreamin', it sure keeps me off the street.

Especially when DHart starts posting pictures of his works of art :)
 
*sigh*

I hear you, orionengnr, but unfortunately I've already got my heart set on a GP100 with a 6" barrel... as well as a buttload of other stuff that I can't afford. Just check out my signature. :(
 
I have both the 2" and 3" Ruger SP101........although small enough to fit into a pocket they will cause your pocket to sag noticably because of the weight.....even in a pocket holster. If I want an all steel revolver for "grab and go" I use one my 19oz. S&W J frames; I wouldn't trade either of my Ruger Sp101's but for "grab and go" I recommend a true S&W J frame. A used model 36 in nice condition shouldn't cost you more than $250. But now we are talking about 38 Special +P...still formidible ...but NOT in the same league as .357.Mag.
If your set on the Ruger and .357 Mag. ,between the 2" and 3" Sp101 I would choose the longer barrel as I like the extra sight radius on the longer barrel. They are fine, well built, little powerhouse revolvers.

-regards
 
Thanks for the help, guys! I think I may go ahead and go with the longer barrel... if I don't end up liking it I suppose I could always sell it back anyway. I have a while left to think about it, too... ain't 21 yet. :(
 
Back
Top