I have a question for those of you who are right up on “what’s what” with regards to the popularity and (approximate) value of old lever action rifles from the Cowboy Era.
I have the option of getting one of the following. Both are completely original, both are in what I would class as “good” condition, and both are in .38-55 caliber.
One is a Winchester Model 1894 Lever Action. I checked the Winchester site and from the serial number I believe this one was made in abut 1916.
The other is a Marlin Model 1893 Lever Action. I can’t find a site that actually gives dates for serial numbers, but based on the serial numbers on other guns I’ve been told about I believe this one was likely made in about 1895 or 1896.
Obviously this is all speculation as I don’t have pictures to show, but assuming both are in perfect mechanical order, and both are in “good” condition (metal and wood), would anybody like to hazard even a ballpark guess as to what each might be worth?
Also, which of the two would be more “desirable” with regards to the Cowboy Action type shooting? The Winchester has the more famous name, but the Marlin is older and was made pre 1900.
At the present time I’m leaning towards trying to make a deal for the Marlin, although I don’t have a clue what to offer.
I’d appreciate any thoughts or opinions.
I have the option of getting one of the following. Both are completely original, both are in what I would class as “good” condition, and both are in .38-55 caliber.
One is a Winchester Model 1894 Lever Action. I checked the Winchester site and from the serial number I believe this one was made in abut 1916.
The other is a Marlin Model 1893 Lever Action. I can’t find a site that actually gives dates for serial numbers, but based on the serial numbers on other guns I’ve been told about I believe this one was likely made in about 1895 or 1896.
Obviously this is all speculation as I don’t have pictures to show, but assuming both are in perfect mechanical order, and both are in “good” condition (metal and wood), would anybody like to hazard even a ballpark guess as to what each might be worth?
Also, which of the two would be more “desirable” with regards to the Cowboy Action type shooting? The Winchester has the more famous name, but the Marlin is older and was made pre 1900.
At the present time I’m leaning towards trying to make a deal for the Marlin, although I don’t have a clue what to offer.
I’d appreciate any thoughts or opinions.
Last edited: