1858 peitta refinishing?

N.Burnham84

Inactive
hello all i am new to the forum and i have a 1858 remington with alot of scratches and tool marks from the factory i am thinking of sanding it down with 400 grit to get it smooth and re blue it any ideas comments is this a bad idea thanks
 
It would depend on how deep the scratches were on your revolver as to what grit of sandpaper you would use. If the scratches are slight and not very deep, I wouldn't use sandpaper at all but use a buffing wheel instead with some rouge. Even if you use 600 grit sandpaper that will not get you the high polish shine you really want. And the better your bare metal preparation (in this case the buffed high gloss shine)....the better it will look when you re-blue it. It's kind of like body work on a car where the job will only look as good as your base preparation. Only more so in this case because bluing does not cover imperfections nearly as well as a thicker coat of auto paint since bluing has practically no thickness at all and the revolver's finish is wholly dependent upon your surface preparation before re-bluing.

If you have one or have a friend who has a bench grinder, you can quickly put a buffing wheel pad on it and using some rouge on the spinning wheel to do the job. Even if you have to use a file in some spots or heavier grit sandpaper to get all the scratches out, you would still be best served to use the buffing wheel as a final operation to mirror polish the bare metal before re-bluing. Actually before you touch it with sandpaper, try a buffing wheel first. Start with a heavier grit of rouge and then go to a smaller grit. You may find you don't even need any sandpaper to do the job. But again, that depends on the depth of the scratches.

Just be VERY careful of the flats on the barrel and other angled parts of the revolver that you do not wear them down and thus round them off with the buffing wheel.





.
 
Last edited:
Get some Belgian Blue from Brownell's. It works great. Strip the old blue with naval jelly or vinegar. Sand the metal with 320 or 400 to start and finish off with 600. I do the final sand/polish with a worn piece of 600. Scrub the metal with hot water and a lot of soap, it must be oil free. Follow the instructions on the bottle.

This is the results.
snubbieproto01.jpg

short01.jpg

leftblue01.jpg

rightblue02.jpg

rightblue01.jpg

snuubie1101.jpg


Avoid using 1000 grit paper, this leaves to fine of finish and the blue does not take as well. The finished job is a tough as any hot blue job.
 
Back
Top